The Lake Geneva Joint #1 School District and Lake Geneva-Genoa City Union (Badger) High School District are committed to transparency and responsible stewardship of public resources.
Because questions have been raised regarding superintendent compensation, the following information provides context about Dr. Peter Wilson's salary and benefits, the responsibilities associated with serving two separate school districts, and how Dr. Wilson’s compensation compares with other area superintendents.
What is the superintendent's salary for the 2025-26 school year?
Dr. Peter Wilson's base salary for the 2025-26 school year was $192,000.
An important part of understanding that figure is the structure of the position. Dr. Wilson serves simultaneously as superintendent of two legally separate school districts: The Lake Geneva Joint #1 School District and Lake Geneva-Genoa City Union (Badger) High School District. The districts have separate school boards, budgets, operations, and governance responsibilities.
The superintendent’s salary and most benefit costs are divided equally between the two districts. This shared model allows two separate districts to obtain superintendent leadership through one position rather than maintaining two.
For the 2025-26 school year, Lake Geneva Joint #1 School District paid $96,000 for the superintendent, and Lake Geneva-Genoa City Union (Badger) High School District paid $96,000.
How does Dr. Wilson's salary compare with other area superintendents?
Dr. Wilson's salary is slightly above several relevant peer-group averages. After excluding one superintendent position that is specifically identified as a two-days-per-week assignment, the remaining 27 positions in the 2025–26 comparison group range from $128,737 to $223,612, with an average of approximately $182,125 per year. (The comparison group excludes the $99,000 Genoa City/Brookwood superintendent position in Walworth County because it is a two-days-per-week assignment, as previously noted).
Two particularly relevant comparison groups are the Southern Lakes Conference and Union High School Districts:
|
Comparison group
|
Average 2025–26 base salary
|
Dr. Wilson's salary
|
|
Southern Lakes Conference
|
$188,662
|
$192,000
|
|
Union High School Districts
|
$188,801
|
$192,000
|
|
All Comparison Districts
|
$182,125
|
$192,000
|
|
Walworth County Districts
|
$165,983
|
$192,000
|
|
K–8 Districts
|
$154,729
|
$192,000
|
Dr. Wilson's $192,000 salary is therefore approximately 1.8% above the Southern Lakes Conference average and 1.7% above the Union High School Districts average. Those are particularly useful comparisons because his compensation is very close to the prevailing salary for superintendents in those peer groups, while his responsibilities extend across two separate school districts.
There is another important distinction when considering individual comparisons. Waterford Union High School District reports a superintendent salary of approximately $210,000, but that superintendent's contract is for only 210 working days. Dr. Wilson's contract establishes a 260-day employment year — 50 additional contract days. Dr. Wilson also serves two separate school districts rather than one.
How does enrollment factor into the comparison?
Enrollment is one useful measure of a superintendent's responsibilities, although it is not the only one. School districts must maintain core leadership and operational functions regardless of size, including budgeting, personnel management, curriculum and instruction, facilities, school safety, regulatory compliance, board governance, family and community relations, and long-range planning.
The comparison is also more meaningful when enrollment, organizational structure, and contract length are considered alongside salary. A superintendent serving one district under a substantially shorter annual contract is not necessarily a direct comparison with a superintendent serving two districts under a 260-day contract. For Dr. Wilson, the scope includes two legally separate districts, two boards of education, two budgets, and a 260-day employment year.
For 2025-26, Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction data show September 2025 adjusted pupil counts of 1,610 students in Lake Geneva Joint #1 and 1,215 in Lake Geneva-Genoa City UHS, or 2,825 students combined.
The following provides additional context using several relevant districts from the salary comparison:
|
School District
|
Sept. 2025
pupil count
|
Contractual Days
|
2025–26 superintendent salary
|
Districts led
|
|
Arrowhead UHS
|
1,696
|
260
|
$223,612
|
1
|
|
Waterford UHS
|
863
|
210
|
$209,529
|
1
|
|
Elkhorn Area
|
2,712
|
260
|
$204,348
|
1
|
|
Lake Geneva Joint #1 & Lake Geneva-Genoa City UHS
|
2,825
combined
|
260
|
$192,000
|
2
|
|
Central/Westosha UHS
|
1,081
|
260
|
$190,858
|
1
|
|
East Troy Community
|
1,549
|
260
|
$184,517
|
1
|
|
Big Foot UHS
|
412
|
260
|
$183,295
|
1
|
|
Wilmot UHS
|
928
|
260
|
$155,000
|
1
|
The enrollment figures above are Wisconsin DPI September 2025 adjusted pupil counts. The salary figures come from the districts' 2025-26 superintendent comparison data.
This comparison illustrates why enrollment and organizational structure provide useful context. For example, Dr. Wilson's $192,000 salary is below the salaries reported for Elkhorn, Arrowhead, and Waterford UHS. At the same time, the combined student population Dr. Wilson oversees equals more than each of those school districts.
Enrollment alone does not determine appropriate superintendent compensation. However, considering enrollment alongside the responsibility for two districts, two boards, and two separate organizations provides a more complete picture than comparing salaries alone.
Why does it matter that the superintendent serves two districts?
Lake Geneva Joint #1 School District and Lake Geneva-Genoa City Union (Badger) High School District are separate governmental entities. Each has its own board, budget, operations, and responsibilities.
The shared model allows both districts to obtain superintendent leadership through one position rather than maintaining two.
For additional market context, the average 2025-26 superintendent salary among the union high school districts in the comparison group is $188,801, while the average among the K-8 districts is $145,441. Dr. Wilson's salary is $192,000 while serving both districts (Lake Geneva Joint #1 Schools and Lake Geneva-Genoa City Union (Badger) High School).
These averages should not be interpreted as a precise calculation of what the districts would spend if they employed two separate superintendents. Rather, they provide useful context for understanding the shared leadership model and the regional market for superintendent compensation.
What retirement benefits do the districts provide the superintendent?
For 2025-26, the two school districts contributed $13,000 to a 403(b) tax-sheltered annuity (TSA) on Dr. Wilson's behalf. A TSA is a typical component of a superintendent's overall compensation package, and should be understood and disclosed as such.
Retirement contributions are one of the tools school boards can use when structuring an executive compensation package. In Dr. Wilson's case, the TSA contribution was $10,200 annually under his 2022-2024 contract, and then $12,500 in 2024-25 and $13,000 in 2025-26.
The TSA should therefore be considered part of Dr. Wilson's total compensation, rather than being viewed separately.
Why does the superintendent receive a vehicle allowance?
Dr. Wilson receives a $400 monthly vehicle allowance (or $4,800 annually) from Lake Geneva Joint #1 for using his personal vehicle for school business.
Dr. Wilson’s responsibilities require travel among schools and district facilities. The allowance helps compensate for business use of a personally owned vehicle rather than requiring the district to provide a vehicle.
The contract also provides reimbursement at the current IRS mileage rate for out-of-district mileage.
To clarify, the $400 monthly payment is a vehicle allowance, not a mileage reimbursement. Mileage for qualifying out-of-district travel is handled separately.
What health insurance benefits does the superintendent receive?
Dr. Wilson does not receive fully district-paid health insurance under his current contract.
Under his original 2022-2024 contract, the two districts paid 100% of his medical, vision, and dental insurance premium. Under the 2024-2026 contract, that provision changed. The boards now contribute the same amount toward the superintendent's medical, vision, and dental insurance that they contribute for professional staff.
This change provides important context when considering how the superintendent's overall benefits have evolved.
What other benefits are included in the superintendent's contract?
The contract includes benefits associated with a year-round leadership position, including long-term disability and life insurance, eight sick days annually, 25 vacation days, two personal days, professional association dues, a $75 per-month cell phone reimbursement, and reimbursement for approved professional development and related expenses.
The superintendent's contract establishes a 260-day employment year, reflecting the year-round nature of the position.
Why do the boards provide these types of benefits?
A superintendent's compensation package helps recruit and retain qualified leadership in a competitive regional labor market. School boards consider the entire compensation package, including salary and benefits, as well as professional qualifications and experience, performance, the scope and complexity of the position, market conditions, and the needs of the districts.
In the case of Lake Geneva Joint #1 School District and Lake Geneva-Genoa City Union (Badger) High School District, the boards also consider the unusual scope of a position, responsible for simultaneously leading two separate school districts.